The oceanfront one bedroom duplex we stayed in was excellent. Both floors, living room and bedroom have magnificent ocean views. There are only a few feet of dunes between the outdoor deck and the actual beach. The deck is larger than your usual hotel/motel's and offers privacy from adjoining decks but still provides a great opening to the ocean. The... more

We recently stayed at the Surf Club in April 2008. I have been going to Montauk for over thirty years and my family has a place there. This week we wanted alone time and booked our stay here. We also stayed here in the fall. Our accommodation was a two bedroom ocean view. The views are beautiful. This is what... more

My husband and I were looking for a place to stay that was a bit roomier than a hotel room for our weeklong vacation in Montauk this year, and we were REALLY pleased with our choice of the Surf Club. We thought about renting a private cottage, but couldn't find anything so close to the ocean, and with a pool... more

We stayed for a week at the Surf Club in an "ocean front" one bedroom. You are basically renting a condo - this is not a resort in the traditional sense. The biggest pro is you can not beat the location. You can hear the waves from your room and the beach in front of the property is clean and... more

This may be a great location, but they are absolutely the most awful staff Ive ever had the unfortunate experience of having to deal with. They made this potenitally beautiful property ugly. I travel quite a bit and had to go out to montauk for a wedding. I booked the room about 3 weeks in advance and had to overnight... more

It doesn't get any better than this place! The condo-style rooms are amazing and this place is literally on the beach. One night here costs more money than most used cars but if you're filthy rich enough to spend over $1000 to stay for 2 weekday nights then go for it. Service could be better but who cares in such... more

We stayed in one of the 1-bedroom beachfront units at the beginning of May (still low season so very reasonably priced). We were right on the beach and had a superb view, it's great being lulled to sleep by the sound of the waves. The unit was clean and well-furnished (apart from the kitchen having no cutlery!). As it was... more

The property was great. We visited in late September, which is off-season and therefore pretty empty. we booked a 1br ocean view - everything new, very private, beautiful view of the ocean. there's beach grass growing in front of the condo so the ocean view rooms don't allow you to walk directly out onto the beach, but you can do... more

We have stayed at the Surf Club for the past ten years and it is unbelievable how nasty the management has become. I guess they figure that they can rent out the rooms anyway so why be nice or accomodating to anyone. We had so many problems with the plumbing in our room. We had a flood and both the... more