Have you ever felt welcome and at home when you entered a hotel of a B&B? I have spent my whole career travelling all over the globe (even to some of the exotic spots Innkeeper Jack has) and never had that feeling ..... until we stepped into Bartlett House. It is a beautiful place, no doubt about that, but Diane... more

This B&B is well-run and beautiful. The owners (Jack and Diane) are world travelers and so the furniture and decor seems to mostly consist of beautiful pieces that they have brought back from their travels. The room we stayed in was filled with items that they had bought while they were in Africa (not sure which country or countries, but... more

The Bartlett House is a beautiful B&B and perfect for anyone who is visiting Long Island for wine tasting or for a holiday. Jack and Dianne (yes, like the song) are lovely folks who run a great place. The B&B is geared towards adults (I wouldn't suggest bringing your young family), and I couldn't say enough wonderful things about the... more

I stayed at the Bartlett House Inn on the recommendation of this website and throughly recommend it to anyone who is wanting to visit the wineries and see the sites of the North Fork of Long Island. Dianne, the Inn Keeper is extremely friendly and very knowledgable about the restaurants. She made some excellent recommendations of places to eat and... more

Stayed 2 days at Bartlett House and enjoyed it. Off season, but we had a great time following the innkeeper's suggestions for seeing Shelter Island and the Hamptons. This Inn is very far east, but still a great, relaxing place to stay. The rooms are incredible... decorated and furnished perfectly (innkeeper used to work for Ethan Allen!) Breakfast was great...... more

My husband and I had the pleasure of staying at the Bartlett House for a few days of quiet time. The inn is clean and bright, filled with beautiful treasures and all the comfort and amenities one would want in a B&B. The Innkeeper Diane was a delight. Her dinner and winery suggestions were on the spot and made our... more

We're from the UK, and on a family vacation to the East Coast we wanted to spend a few days on Long Island before our visit to Manhattan, and we couldn't have had a better place to stay. Greenport itself is a lovely town - quaint but not pretentious - and there are plenty of beaches to explore, some good... more

The Bartlett House Inn is a beautiful place, but the owner is NOT hospitable at all. She was rude, and not accommodating in any way. The breakfast was horrible as well. She would bring out one plate at a time of cold cuts and prepared foods. Nothing was made. She was really difficult to deal with. It really was the... more

My cousin had her wedding in Greenport, NY on October 3, 2008. We chose the Bartlett Inn because it was located next door to the church she was getting married at. Our stay and experience at the Inn was not a good one. It was truly a very disappointing and will never recommend it to anyone. The Inn Keeper was... more