Wow…Much to my surprise…… After reading mixed comments from others I was reluctant to book, I gave it a shot and boy am I glad I did. The reservations staff was so helpful and accommodating (I must admit I’m not an easy customer) and they handled very question and request with such grace and eagerness through-out the entire call. I... more

The rooms look about a hundred years old... incredibly dated. The wireless "high-speed" internet couldn't be further from the truth. After complaining to the front desk they gave me a something to plug into my computer which only marginally improved the speed. It was still too slow to stream even simple audio (internet radio). In the gym most of the... more

My husband and I stayed here for a wedding and it was awful on every front. You want to check in before 3pm? Dream on. You booked a room with a king size bed? Too bad, here's a double. The guy at the front desk had a terrible attitude and wasn't even apologetic. The room itself was uncomfortable and in... more

We chose the Garden City Hotel because we were attending a wedding in the area and the rehersal dinner was at the hotel. Several guests were from out of town, and other guests were members of the wedding party. The rehesal was scheduled for 5 PM, to be followed immediately by dinner. However, when we arrived for 3 PM check... more

In short...I would be embarrased to have friends or family stay at the Garden City Hotel. Some reasons: -check-in was at 3pm and I was not able to actually check-in until 5:30pm -room looked like it was last refreshed in 1887, smelled funny, no view, mediocre air conditioning, old beds -room lacked basic ameneties such as an iron. even after... more

Stayed at the Garden City Hotel for the Belmont Stakes Weekend. Won a sweepstakes and this hotel was included in the Grand Prize. What a wonderful, luxury hotel. Garden City, LI is a beautiful location and the hotel was just as beautiful. The Staff was more than helpful and accessible and most of all friendly. Yes, it is an older... more

The Garden City Hotel is an absolutely luxurious hotel! Everything is wonderfully appointed throughout the hotel itself and it's rooms. The staff are friendly and helpful, as well as very knowledgable. We were here for a "wedding weekend" for a friend of ours. Their entire wedding - from the ceremony, to the food, to the decor - was amazingly beautiful... more

This is a very pretentious hotel that offers nothing except attitude. We called room service for a cork screw. They wanted $50 for a cork screw. I also got charged for snack bar even though I didn't consume anything. I contacted their accounting department, but they didn't care what I had to say. I will never ever stay here. more

I stayed at the hotel twice for business and everyone was surprised that my company would let me stay at such a nice place. That set expectations pretty high. When I arrived it appeared to live up to the expectations of a high class hotel. Valet parking only (even though the empty parking lot was 100 feet away) and everyone... more