Finished a stay with colleagues at the Gray Barn Cottage, in it's "undisclosed location" - gotta say, it's kind of annoying when you try to book this expensive house, and they won't tell you where it is until you check in - but it is truly fabulous. If you're curious, it's on Buell Lane, still within the village, and a... More

The Inn is found across the street from the famous EH windmill and in season I guess that guests breakfast in the sun room over looking the yellow landmark. We arrived on a bleak wintery day in January and found the dining room very charming. . As a matter of fact, having been in EH many times during the summer,... More

My boyfriend and I came here for a relaxing weekend away from the city and had the perfect vacation. The staff was wonderful and from the very beginning, by allowing us to check in early, explaining what everything was in the well-stocked mini-bar with every kind of soda, juice, as well as cookies, snacks, and even fruit and cheese platters,... More

Stayed there last Summer to the tune of $1500 per night.We had the worst experience and would never stay there again.They don't care about service or making the guest happy.We had many problems including being locked out of our room serveral times by their "new" system and they wouldn't do a thing about it. I would never stay there again... More

We used it as a base to explore Sag Harbour and the rest of the Hamptons. Came from Perth Australia and stayed for 2 days in December (should have been at least a week) after a week in NYC, and from the time we walked in till the reluctant goodbyes, it was perfect. The complimentary snacks, freshly baked items and... More

We, again, came for our anniversary which is a perfect time in October. We stayed in the same suite as we did last. We requested it as it was wonderful, quiet and tucked away. Everything was wonderful as expected but unfortunately the mattress needs to be replaced as it was way too soft with dips on both sides which made... More

Travelled from Australia, had just finished the marathon in NYC, and the Mill House Inn absolutely exceeded expectations. Well done to the staff - so very friendly, yet relaxed, the room was stunning - no shortcuts in fitting and maintaining the room, and the attention to detail was impressive - from complimentary snacks/juices downstairs to the delicious (complimentary) goodies in... More

We went with another couple for 2 nights at the beginning of November. Suite on the main floor (only 1) was super - steam shower, fireplace, pre evening drinks with our friends. Walking distance to the main street and some wonderful restaurants. The staff was accommodating, amenities, including fresh baked cookies, cheese plate, all self serve. Like a B&B ,... More

We came here in May for our mini-honeymoon. The Inn is pricey, but definitely well worth it. The all of the Inn staff are extremely friendly, and they go above and beyond to offer exceptional service. This is by far the nicest place I have ever stayed. There is always fresh baked goods and drinks downstairs for you, and the... More