If you appreciate unique architecture and high quality design, you will love this historic inn. Everything about the Roycroft was beautiful, from its picturesque location in lovely East Aurora to the decorative murals in the lobby and the warm, inviting ambiance in the public spaces. Our room, on the first floor of the adjoining Guest House, was pristine and well-appointed.... more

The Inn is absolutely spectacular and beautifully furnished. You won't find finishing touches like this at a Best Western. I have never seen such generously sized guestrooms. These are not your standard cookie-cutter L-shaped hotel rooms. The bathroom alone is larger than some hotel rooms. And the furniture is not cheap laminated pressboard but authenic (modern) Stickley re-issues. It really... more

We have nothing but wonderful things to say about the Roycroft Inn and it's staff. Our room was more than comfortable and the service was exceptional. It is an older, historic hotel so expect some creaking but it just lends charm. more

I grew up very near the Roycroft Inn and stay there when I return to visit family. I haven't had the same problems as others on the site in terms of service, noise, or general discomfort. The rooms are beautiful, but yes they are expensive, especially if you begin to expand to the three or four room suites. I have... more

This was to be a surprise New Years Eve Getaway. We arrived from Canada around 5 ish. Had booked a room on second floor of main building but werre given a room in the guest house which of course we questioned but were told there were no more rooms in the main building. Not only was the room in the... more

Yes, the Roycroft is a beautiful property, but I only stay there now when the Hampton Inn is full. I have stayed at the Roycroft over a dozen times during the past few years and have suffered many of the same issues as have been mentioned on this site (especially the sound from adjoining and rooms above!). I have mentioned... more

The hotel should be ashamed for charging what it did for a one night stay. Granted, the place is rustic, but we had a so-called "five room suite" on the first floor, and paid $250 for a room where it was impossible to get any sleep. We had a room on the first floor - there was an 18 inch... more

We stayed at this hotel over the Labour Day weekend. Food was wonderful and the Sunday brunch was lovely. However, the beds and pillows were so uncomfortable .. never have a slept in a worst bed, anywhere. Hard, lumpy ... just plain bad. Loved the rooms and the ambiance, just replace the darn bedding!!! more

We didn't stay at the Roycroft because of what we read on this very website. So yes, the reviews online matter. We did have lunch here, and thought the service in the dining area (we dined on the outside porch) was very friendly, although we aren't big fans of the habit of seating customers in a small area within a... more