Okay hotel and good value compared to Manhattan. Only about 10 min to walk to the train and the 20 min by train to Penn Station on Manhattan. First when we arrived it was very cold in our room and it was not possible to turn on any heating. We asked for extra blankets but did not get any. We... more

I stayed here for a night during a layover. The hotel was clean, and the rooms were small but serviceable. I don't have a lot of nice things to say about the location, but then again, I don't have a lot of nice things to say about Newark. It's not too far from the PATH train and the airport shuttle... more

I had previously written a review of the Robert Treat Hotel and had commented on how it needed updating. Well I was pleasantly surprised when I stayed here again and the hotel had been renovated. The hotel is now a Best Western hotel and the rooms have undergone a major renovation. The carpet and furniture have all been replaced and... more

I stayed here one night with a friend who was departing from Newark Airport. While small, the room was stylishly decorated and clean. Parking was convenient in back of the hotel, and I could see my car out the window. There was a party going on on the first floor, but our floor was very quiet. We walked to breakfast... more

I've stayed a few times now at the Robert Treat and always enjoy my stays. The cost is considerably lower than what you can find in Manhattan, and with the convenient PATH trains, it's only a 20 minute ride into the City. The PATH station is a pleasant four block walk away from the hotel. The hotel itself is in... more

Hotel was clean and in good condition. The room was a little small but had a large desk and work area if you are traveling on business. The bed and linen were comfortable but the pillows were too soft. The bathroom was very small with a vent that could not be turned off, so it created a draft which made... more

My friend and I stayed here as a cheeper alternative to a New York hotel. Thankfully it was only for three nights. The room and facilities were clean and spacious - very good value for the price we paid. However, the staff were another story. One sent us in the wrong direction when we were looking for breakfast (which was... more

Myself and my family stayed at this hotel for 3 nights as a base for visiting New York City. I booked 3 rooms online (1 king room non smoking, 1 queen room smoking and a room with 2 double beds non smoking). but the staff managed to get all 3 of these rooms wrong!! We asked to change one of... more

We chose the Robert Treat Hotel based on reviews we found on trip advisor as well as advice from a friend on driving to New York City (he said stay in Newark...good call!). Cost was an absolute bargain at $85 per night which we booked online on their website based on a prepaid rate (check restrictions if you do this).... more