Got here at 12pm and was told my boyfriend and I had to wait until 3 to check in and that They would call us. They didn't call us and by 2:15pm I decided to Stop by again to see what was up. They checked and it seemed like the key was prepared and They didn't call us on purpose... More

First time stay in Cape May. The hotel staff was very helpful and friendly. Arrived a bit early and the desk attendant told us she would call us on our cell as soon as the room was ready. The bar and restaurant were awesome as well as the beach side service. You really can't beat the value as most of... More

We stayed here in May 2012. .It was our first time visiting Cape May. We had a great stay here. We stayed one night. Our room was on the second floor and faced the ocean. The check in desk people were very friendly. There was a bar and a restaurant right downstairs. Everything in town was also just a few... More

Some of the negative reviews are a little harsh. The hotel is not a dump. We stayed here back when the hotel was named the Coachman's Motor Inn as well as the Beach Shack. To be honest, it's better as the beach shack! It's in a good location and the Rusty Nail is a great spot to grab a drink... More

The place is very convenient to the beach and the hotel has free beach chairs and umbrellas and serving on the beach etc. But the thing with the rooms is that the door is at the front of the room on a common walkway balcony facing the beach. Basically whoever designed the building should have put all that at the... More

This place was weeks from being torn down and replaced with a super fancy time share resort, before the economy tanked in 2008/9. I think the group who owns it is just waiting for real estate to stabilize a little more before the Beach Shack is gone.

I believe that any 4-5 ratings received by this place are actually written by employees because there is no way anyone in their right mind would rate this place that high......unless of course you don't mind spending a good deal of money to stay in a place that is comparable to a slum. To begin, the carpets are dirty and... More

This place is the old coachmans motor inn that is now under new management. The rooms have been updated a little & the old dark rusty skupper bar & restaurant turned into a "hip" new outdoor/indoor bar. Was expecting a little more change because the price is now doubled from what is was before. The rooms have been painted, new... More

My husband and I had a wonderful overnight anniversary in Cape May We were very happy with the Beach Shack-very clean-nice view of the ocean, the fire pit was nice at night. My husband had flowers delivered to me and they were waiting in the room. We would stay here again. The bed and pillows were super comfy