My husband and I did not realize that the hotel had an 11am check-out time. We came back to our room at 11:50am from a brunch to pack up and check out only to find our room completely empty. The hotel staff had packed up all of our stuff (very randomly) and essentially kicked us out. Our bags were sitting... more

Look I am a mother of two and the fact that some people say this is a great family place is scary to me. One of my daughters has asthma and if I would have had her with me there is no way we would have been able to stay because the mold and mildew were aweful. That being said... more

If you like non air-conditioned rooms and midlew...this is the place for you. My wife and another couple rented a 2 bedroom "vila". When we unlocked the door we found out that there was no air-conditioning...it has a strong mildew smell and the furnitre was outdated by at lease 30 years. 3 fans were provided in which one did not... more

Edgartown Commons is in a great location. The units are individually owned so each has its own personality. This was our second visit. Our first was 17 years ago and not much has changed. The pool is wonderful. Our unit this time was very dated. We stayed in 21. The carpets are in dire need of cleaning. The kids were... more

After reading a few of these less than stellar reviews, I was somewhat dubious about our upcoming stay at Edgartown Commons. My fears were 100% unfounded. Our apartment was AWESOME. We had a spacious 2 bedroom unit with a huge living room, 1.5 baths, a good-sized kitchen and a dining area with a table for 6. Sliding doors opened up... more

Great location without a doubt! Nice pool and play ground for kids but dont be hoodwinked... Bedding is old, dirty and was in dire need of replacement 10 yrs ago! The toilet seat was cracked in multiple spots, just plain old gross and the bathroom walls were cracked with mildew (YUCK) Furniture could be tossed out for trash and lets... more

I read the reviews too, but notice how old they are, someone took this place in hand and made it fresh and inviting. , For the money it was my best choice. Was I pleasantly surpised, the room was clean, the people were pleasant. Yes there is no air, which is true of about 80% of the island rooms, for... more

Several of us stayed at the Edgartown Commons for a few days this summer. I had read a few negative reviews but was pleasantly surprised when we arrived. Although the rooms were not entirely modern and the bathrooms were old, they were comfortable and cottage-like. We enjoyed having the kitchen and living room area and the location of the hotel... more

We had read some "iffy" reviews on Trip Advisor, so we were a little nervous, but we were SO pleased with our stay. True, there's no maid service, but guess what - I don't have daily maid service at home either, so it was no biggie. The suite was perfect for our family; we were able to put our kids... more