The Whitetail Club has now been renamed the Shore Lodge. My husband & I stayed two nights during Thanksgiving. Sumptious lakeview room with separate sitting room from the bedroom giving an apartment feel & plenty of space. We pulled two overstuffed chairs to the large window, propped our slippered feet on the windowsill & enjoyed the beautiful view of the... more

The Whitetail Club is now Shorline Lodge I've heard -- change in ownership but (hopefully) still same great facilities, room set up and perhaps lower rates to attract more people? We've stayed there for a week to 10 days for the past three years during July and for our family of four (our two boys are now 14 and 10)... more

I was living in the McCall area this summer and a group of friends and I decided on lunch and facials at the Whitetail. Lunch was good, nothing that was mind blowing, but good and satisfying. The view over Payette lake is amazing and it was great to sit back and take it all in. The Spa was AMAZING! The... more

I found the club to be a great venue. It has outstanding views. The food was great .The service was okay. I was well informed of the rooms on the first floor and there lack of a/c.I read some of the other reviews,and foud it hard to believe that the other guest were not informed of this.But the room on... more

It is very difficult to beat the beauty of McCall, Idaho and the gorgeous setting of the Whitetail Club. Having said that, the customer service of this hotel leaves a lot to be desired. To put it succinctly, it is absolutely horrible. From the unaccommodating meeting coordinator with the terrible attitude to the rude front desk and general service personnel,... more

As a very frequent traveler, I rely heavily on Tripadvisor. However, I have learned that people expect different things from their vacations. And, depending on the purpose of my trip, so do I. With this in mind, let me HIGHLY recommend this hotel for a romantic getaway. The rooms are spacious and well appointed with robes and balconies. The restauratn... more

One of the most fabulous places we have ever stayed! An absolutely beautiful mountain lodge. We were there last November and we felt like we had our own mountain mansion! I believe there were only 2 other guest rooms occupied. Our family had 2 suites that could be closed off together. The suites are gorgeous and well worth the price.... more