Atlantic Bay Resort is an older facility which could use some updating, pretty typical of a lot of places in the keys. I didn’t see evidence of bugs nor was the place dirty. Bathroom and shower were fine. Kitchen was older and equipped but we only used glasses for the wine we brought and a couple plates for chips and... More

A decent place to stay. The grounds are kept very clean and neat and there is a small beach for access to the gulf. You can snorkel around in the shallow waters, just watch for the Cassiopeia jelly fish laying on the bottom. When stepped on, they emit a mucous that can sting you if you're not moving. We stayed... More

My wife and I have stayed at this resort many times. Any room is excellent, the dock is awesome, the pool is very nice and the rooms are perfect. After a day on the boat, what better place to relax then at their BBQ grille by the waters edge watching the sunset fall into the water! All of the staff:... More

My friend, his wife and I stayed here last Oct. When we arrived, the managers had taped our room kes to the outside of the office door. As they were walking out they told us there had been some racoons and babies on the property and they were taking them to the local animal shelter, for us just to go... More

In reference to two reviews, Cathy F and Seth_V I (a guest) was directly involved with the individuals who were responsible for creating such a high degree of ill will towards guests and the hotel management. I have never in my travels met a group of people who were so selfish and had such disregard for other guests experience. I... More

we stayed there in april for two nights. the resort is very nice, clean and quiet. they also had a free baby bed for our son :) the pool is nice as well, unfortunately there isn't really e beach. but there's a nice pier and some canvas chairs by the ocean to watch the sunset. More

I stayed at the Atlantic Bay resort when the drunks from Miami were thrown off of the property. The office staff went out of their way to accomodate them but when they became abusive, tried to commandeer the property, have hoards of family members as guests, become staggering drunk, and threaten the owner, they were tossed. You don't park your... More

My husband and I had the oceanfront suite-great accomodation. Very comfortable and clean w/kitchenette-perfect for our 5-days. Quiet beach w/ palm trees-have a "carribean feel". Great private resort for couples-we even had the pool to ourselves one afternoon-everyone else was out sight seeing. More

I am writing this review to warn anyone who has children and who wants to have a good time to NOT go to this place. The grounds are beautiful, the room was ok, not for the price. Our group was there to celebrate my little girls birthday, unfortunately someone out of another room, not in my room had a disagreement... More