Great place to stay right on the Florida Bay. Easy access to Route 1 so that you can explore the other Keys, but still quiet. Best place to watch the sunset is on the peninsula on the other side of the boat dock. We stayed in one of the efficiencies that had a fridge, microwave and stove. Great way to... more

We stayed in the Heron Room which is the smallest one they have available. Our friends were getting married right down the street and I just couldn't see paying $200 a night at that resort. I found Atlantic Bay and it was perfect! The room was small but we weren't there that much. We liked the small frig, microwave and... more

As you pull into the resort you instantly feel as if you have been taken to a place far, far away place, like the places of the rich and famous. The staff was very friendly and always willing to give great suggestions on how to get the most out of your stay. The room streamed relaxation, giving off that perfect... more

We just got back from our anniversary stay at Atlantic Bay and could not have been more pleased with our choice. We stayed in the Orchid Suite, located just off of the beach, across from the pool. The room was very spacious, well laid out, with a nice kitchen w/microwave, stove top (no oven) and full size refrigerator/freezer. A sofa,... more

We stayed here for 3 nights with friends. A little close for comfort with another couple, our cottage did not have a regular door to the bedroom and the bathroom was only accessible through our bedroom, they slept on the futon in the living room. Other than that, what a great time! You CAN snorkel from here, the beach is... more

My partner and I stayed at the Atlantic Bay Resort earlier this month. After going to Key West on many occasions over the past 20 years, we wanted to try something different and explore one of the other keys. After researching many places on line, we zeroed in on the Key Largo area. Trip Advisor was very instrumental in our... more

I stayed at the Atlantic Bay Resort with my husband and daughter just before Christmas, 2008. We had never been to the Keys before, so I used TripAdvisor and other web sites to scout places to stay. Based on good reviews and photos of the property, we decided on Atlantic Bay. We were not disappointed. We were in Cottage #1,... more

This hotel is fantastic! We stayed in Room 11 and it was spotless and looked exactly like the pictures on Atlantic Bay’s website. The bed was extremely comfortable and the kitchen was stocked with plenty of dishes. The grounds are beautiful and immaculate. There are beach chairs, grills, and even a hammock on the beach. As other reviews have brought... more

We just returned from a perfect birthday weekend! We stayed in cottage # 2. Very clean,cute, cozy & private. The pool is right across from the cottage (but very private due to the landscaping) It was very refreshing to relax in after a day spent on the water. However we didn't spend much time in our cottage because we took... more