We stayed at Alexander’s for the first time last week and can’t begin to think of enough superlatives to describe our experience. From the moment we arrived we felt as if we were “home” both in terms of the welcome we received from the staff and the wonderful, cozy ambiance. The historic building is magnificently maintained both inside and out,... More

When we got the taxi to Alexanders the taxi driver asked us where we were staying and when we told her she said it was the best place to stay in Key West and she wasn't wrong. Jeff made us feel immediately welcome. Our room was light, the bathroom was small but as an added bonus we had a small... More

The front desk staff was amazing. We didn't have any prearranged plans when we got to Key West. At check in I mentioned that I wanted to ride a jet ski and eat great food. The desk staff made all of our reservations then called and sent an email of where we needed to be when and arranged our transportation.... More

This was our first trip to Key West, and my husband and I loved the island and our stay at Alexander's Guest House! At the time we booked it wasn't possible to have the same room for 7 nights (due to other reservations), but Agnes worked out a schedule so we spent 3 nights in room 1 and 4 nights... More

My partner and I stayed at Alexander's for 4 days and had a great stay. We got to meet some great people, relax and unwind in a most pleasant setting. When I go back however, I would choose another room - not that inside the room wasn't great, it's just that room 7 is right by the bar and as... More

So, I'm currently on the roof of this lovely establishment writing this review before my departure tomorrow because I love this place that much I couldn't wait. When we arrived we were greeting with smiling faces and escorted to our rooms. We are staying in room 8. (pictures included) The room is very nice but the ceilings are low over... More

This was the second time I have stayed there, but first by myself. Last time in room 10, this time in room 9. I love this place - let me say that first. But I have to tell you that if your thinking about staying here by yourself and you can choose between room 3 and 8 or 9. Choose... More

Please read all the other reviews because the message is common to all. Alexanders is truly different. It is like having your own place in paradise . Please join the many people who return every year , you will not be disappointed. It is a long way from the UK but it is worth it for the service, atmosphere, the... More

Being quite the creature of habit and after 12 years of frequenting Key West…I always stay at Alexander's. In my opinion, there is NO better accommodation in Key West! …they never fail to meet my expectation for casual island elegance and service. The staff is spectacular and extremely accommodating of anything that you need and reasonably ask. ...WATCH OUT, MR.... More