My girlfriend and I stayed at the Mermaid & Alligator for three nights. It's a lovely home in Old Town Key West. Immediately felt comfortable and at home with Geri, Dean & Caroline. Not to mention the beautiful dogs Havana & Caya! Stayed in the Bamboo Room which was just what we wanted for a quiet, relaxing time in Key... more

We stayed here in Nov 2008 after having experienced 4 other Key West accomodations on previous holidays. All have been lovely with one of them constantly rated No.1 on Tripadvisor, but we can honestly say that the M & A is the best! Considering all that is included in the price ie. freshly cooked hot entree for breakfast, complimentary cold... more

All the other reviews we read about the Mermaid and The Alligator are right on. Super surroundings - so many nice touches make it feel less like a tourist destination and more like an exotic getaway. The statue of a Mermaid and the Alligator overlooks the pool that is refreshing and perfect for cooling off after day out exploring. The... more

After much research of every hotel and B & B in Key West my wife and I decided on the M&A and we were not disappointed. It was above our expectations.........We had the Audobon Room and it was great! Very comfortable king size bed, jacuzzi tub, and a 5 ft shower next to it. The gardens outside are extremely beautiful... more

My husband and I stayed at the Mermaid & The Alligator for two nights on Aug 12 & 13(this was the second leg of our trip, we stayed at another establishment earlier in the week). I absolutely loved all the lush trees, flowers, plants. From the very moment we arrived we were very welcomed and were greeted by their two... more

After extensive research on Key West lodging for my upcoming trip in December, I chose to contact the Mermaid and Alligator. The B&B has an excellent record of reviews, is highly recommended, and looks beautiful from the pictures posted here. Obviously that comes from a history of great customer service, but unfortunately I feel this situation is not a reflection... more

My husband and I visited the M&A in mid May and had a wonderful time! We made our decision to stay there based on the great reviews that it got through trip advisor. As many of you know, there aren't many places out there that get so many positive reviews! We arrived just in time for the "happy hour" and... more

The Mermaid and the Aliigator is a beautiful B&B set in its own lush gardens on one of Key West's main streets. We had 2 comforable rooms away from the main house in a building on the edge of the garden. Our rooms used to be cigar makers 'cottages' - beautifully renovated and furnished, with a shared porch. We were... more

We are SO glad we did not stay at a hotel. M & A was PERFECT. The owners are very gracious hosts. Breakfasts were delicious. Interiors are very warm and inviting and tastefully furnished. The property is lushly landscaped and divided into several smaller garden sitting areas. Everything was immaculate and well cared for. I especially appreciated all the very... more