We stayed in accommodation on first floor on the front: Positives - Beautiful property and grounds - Good location - 5 minutes to Duval Street - Excellent swimming pool area - Big porch area - One nice bedroom Negatives - Road works outside starting at 8am - cutting concrete is not a nice noise to wake up to - Breakfast... more

Extremely clean! We stayed 5 nights. Great location for walking but we did rent scooters to explore more of the city. Adequate continental breakfast. Beautiful lush gardens. Friendly and helpful staff. more

Short getaway with my wife, brother and sister in law. We got two rooms that were much larger than what I am used to in Key West. Although it was one large room, they had them divided into a sleep area and a sitting area. Plenty of walk around room. There are several two story cottages hidden in deep foliage.... more

We took the ferry from Ft. Meyers to Key West, and my 80-year old mother, sister, daughter and I enjoyed our two-night stay. The old world charm of the three-story hotel was evident. We chose one of the large one-bedroom suites with a large verandah. Choose one of the end units which provides an outdoor sitting area. We also found... more

Just back from Key West, and we really enjoyed our stay at the Island City House. The hotel itself is beautiful, with relaxing gardens and a peaceful pool area. But the best part for us was the location. Close to the Key West Bight and the Old Harbor area filled with great restaurants and places to stop and watch the... more

We stayed at the Island City House in March. I was very impressed with the room we had which was a king suite in the Cigar House. The room was very large, clean and well appointed. The shower was great --nice and hot with a lot of pressure. The refrigerator was awesome, so was the microwave and the granite counters.... more

We had previously booked a room at a different bed & breakfast and felt as though we were settling... then, we stumbled upon the Island City House on Trip Advisor a month before our trip and decided to cancel our other reservation. We're so glad we did! The accommodations were ideal, everything we needed, location great! The breakfast trolley is... more

We read great reviews about this place so we booked it. The price was very inflated. The furnishings were extremely poor quality - the kind you might find for $200 or at a yard sale. The couch and bed were newish but extremely uncomfortable, lacking a normal amount of padding. When we broke out the blanket it was covered with... more

Everywhere else was booked in Key West, so I took an opening here. Was not pleased with what I received for the price. Would not recommend. Would preferred to have, for the price, stayed at the Marriott. more