First of all shocked that a lunch crab claw plate (cold crab in shell at that) with a scoop of nothing special potato salad and coleslaw could fetch a $33 "market" price. Expensive lesson learned. Atmosphere and historical relevance is amazing, but styrofoam and plastic utensils at the prices they charge are a bit disappointing. The mahi and burgers received... More

Our friends & family visited Cabbage Key for dinner - great service, delicious food & incredible atmosphere. If the Triple Tail fish, grilled shrimp, house dressing & housemade rolls aren't enough of a reason to get you there, let me tell you about the amazing Cabbage Key family who became our heroes. We (5 adults & 3 children) went over... More

The setting of the Inn is great, and staying here is ideal for nature lovers. The strongest thing here was the excellent and friendly service - reading some of the other reviews they must definitely have taken criticisms on board, as the service was close to faultless. The manageress seemed very much "on the ball." We stayed in the inn,... More

We visited Cabbage Key for lunch as part of the Tropic Star cruise to Cayo Costa. Having read previous reviews, my expectations were not very high but figured it's only a lunch stop. Our boat captain provided recommendations for the beans and rice with blackened mahi which I ordered. It was the best tasting lunch I have had in a... More

Quite simply, the food was average at best. My drink had a piece of shrimp shell in it and it was pretty gross. We had a party of 4 with two children under a year old. The tip was automatically billed because our children (who were too young for solid food) counted as the 6 people needed for automatically billing... More

Recently went on King Fisher fleet from punta gorda to Cabbage Key. The trip was okay somewhat slow . When we arrived we had 1 1/2 hour to get in very crowded restaurant and eat. We were told to wait in the crowded bar until our name was called. (had to stand) When we were finally seated the menu is... More

Took out of state guests by boat for lunch. Food and service good but upon arrival were met by a very surly dock hand which left a bad impression with us and our guests. Won't go back and definitely won't recommend to other boaters.

Arrived on the tropic star cruise which was excellent. Oredered the signature cheeseburger which arrived on a paper plate - very dry with a slaw side. There was extreme pressure to eat as quicly as possible and vacate the table ready for the next crowd of people arriving on a double decker ferry. Cannot in any way say this was... More

Most people come to Cabbage Key for lunch, but to really experience this remote location you need to stay here. It does not offer the luxuries of a resort or mainland hotel, but the trade off is peace and quiet on a private island with only a few other cabins and inn rooms. We booked a water taxi with Island... More