I have had the pleasure of staying at the Carlisle House on two different occasions, once in Polpis and once in Sankaty. Heather and her staff were very friendly and helpful, offering wonderful suggestions for sightseeing and dining. The rooms were very charming and comfortable, and conveniently set at affordable prices. The decor is historical and interesting, which really gives... more

A delightful and endearing historic inn. Wonderful staff with an especially hospitable innkeeper. Very close to town, and yet private enough to enjoy a quiet and relaxing weekend. I cannot wait to return!!! more

I had a wonderful stay at the Carlisle House Inn. I spent the weekend with many close friends and we all adored the furnishings and setting of the Inn. The Inn could not be in a better location; it is a 2 minute walk from Main Street-- incredibly close, but still on a very quiet street. The hosts were very... more

The Carlisle House Inn is as charming during the "off-season" as it is in the summer months. My husband and I brought my eighty-five-year-old mother to the island to visit friends in November, and we stayed at the Inn for the weekend. My mother was able to stay in the first-floor room, which was perfect for her, and my husband... more

This was my first weekend trip to Nantucket and I was very excited. Based on a recommendation from a mutual friend, we booked the Carlisle House Inn without doing much research. Upon arrival, we had to ring the bell 3 times before anyone came to check us in. Because we were getting in later at night (9pm), I had called... more

We are frequent visitors to Nantucket, and have stayed at different B&B and Inns on each of our visits. We found the Carlisle House to be a nice establishment with a gracious host and an extremely convenient location in the downtown district. The inn was exactly as pictured on their website and as described. When we arrived early in the... more

Charming B&B, close to town,great breakfast, quiet at night, comfortable bed. Heather, the owner couldn't have been more helpful. We meet wonderful people at breakfast and the Saturday wine and cheese gathering where Heather also joined us and had lots of suggestions for meals and activities. more

Well. Let me start out by saying we LOVED Nantucket. What a great little place to relax. As for this particular B&B. Not so much. Ill break this down by good and bads to keep it easy to read. The Good: Location is wonderful. Short walk from the dock. Authentic Old House Owner did small load of laundry for us... more

I was delighted with my stay at this lovely Nantucket B and B on North Water St. It was a short walk from the ferry, the front door is always open. My second floor room was small but suitable for one. It was charming and clean with an air conditioner, cable tv and free internet access. I enjoyed talking with... more