We absolutely loved staying at the Hotel Il Bargellino. Days spent sight seeing and then back to the hotel to relax on the terrace with Carmel, Pino and several other guests staying there. The hotel is just what you need, we had a comforable bed, a bathroom, a refrigerator in our room and close to everything. Thank you for a... more

The hotel Il bargellino is in a covenient location, especially if travelling by train. Our family truly felt welcome at the hotel from the minute we arrived. Afternoons on the patio always were great. Whether drinking wine or having one of Pinos spurr of the moment bruchettas. Just be careful to hit the sack before 3 am.... The hotel was... more

This was my third stay with Carmel and Pinot at Hotel Il Bargellino. The hotel is in a perfect location: close to the train station and close to the Duomo. The proprietors Carmel and Pinot are helpful, accomodating, and very personable. although breakfast is not served, Carmel offers a "cofee set-up" for the morning if you tell her. She is... more

We have stayed at Hotel Il Bargellino four times. We have enjoyed the hospitality of Carmel & Pino. It is located close to muesums, train station, the marketplace and great restaurants. The terrace on the second floor is fantastic. We would sit out after a long day of shopping and sightseeing drinking local wine and enjoying the atmosphere. We are... more

My daughter and I traveled to Florence as a college graduation gift. Il Bargellino came recommended to us by friends and we were not disappointed. Il Bargellino is a small, intimate hotel. Carmel and Pino, the proprietors, are friendly, helpful, and attentive. They made museum reservations for us, recommended wonderful restaurants and pizza cafes. The hotel is very convenient to... more

The rooms were very spacious and clean, there’s a great terrace outside, but most importantly, Carmel and Pino are the most amazing hosts. They were so helpful, warm and friendly, they even threw us a birthday party which they invited all the other guests to! The hotel is very close to the Central Market and San Lorenzo market, walking distance... more

I have stayed at Hotel Il Bargellino a couple times with my boyfriend and we both had a fantastic time. The Owners, Carmel and Pino are the some of the most wonderful people we have ever met. They books tickets to the museums for us so it was easier for us to go sight seeing. They also had recommended amazing... more

Very nice basic hotel located about 5 minutes' walk from the SMN train station. Spacious, clean room. No TV. Cool terrace to hang out on. Watch out for the parrot - he bites! I did want to share one tip about finding the place. When you reserve the room in advance, Carmel sends you an email with detailed directions on... more

I also booked this 'hotel' due to the rave reviews posted here, and have mixed feelings. While the owners seemed nice enough rarely did I see them during the stay so I can't really speak to that too much. In comparison to the prices I paid in Venice, Tuscany and Rome it is cheaper though when you convert the Euro... more