The location of Kildonan is very good to reach the city center in few minutes by bus. The accomodation is lovely, with comfortable rooms and a very good service. Take the chance of having dinner in the hotel because the Restaurant is also very good. more

We stayed for 7 nights and thoroughly enjoyed the friendly atmosphere, helpful staff, comfortable beds (although the rooms were a shade smaller than we expected) and an excellent restaurant. Our visit was mainly geared to visiting friends of long-standing so the Kildonan was a good choice as it is well situated for easy access to the City centre and the... more

This was our 2nd stay at Kildonan Lodge – so we must like it! The weather on this visit wasn’t as kind as the previous stay, but the Kildonan certainly did everything possible to make the stay just as enjoyable. As with our last visit we were greeted by our friendly Canadian who, again sorted out taxis and restaurant bookings... more

Well we stayed for 2 nights and only wish we didnt have to go home. We were met at the front door by a very helpful and professional young lady. Nothing was too much trouble and we were completley at ease with our one year old daughter being with us. The food was sensational and the room was beautiful, it... more

Got here a bit early & our room (naturally enough) wasn't ready,but the very attractive receptionist couldn't have been nicer or more helpful. While waiting we were shown into the residents lounge with its honesty bar,which i was ready for after getting lost driving round Edinburgh(thanks Google). As i was having a well earned beer the receptionist came in &... more

The Kildonan Lodge Hotel.Edinburgh This was our first visit to Edinburgh,so it was a long shot at picking the hotel,we booked an 'executive room" which was adequate but small and a bit tired,bed and pillows were sooo comfortable.very,very quite,Bar was help your self!and just write it down what you have had,very trusting. We felt having 4 stars the Ex.rooms could... more

I stayed at Kildonan Lodge earlier this year, on a complete whim as I had to free weeks and nothing to do with them! I booked it almost at the last minute, but had quite high expectations as my AA hotel guide book gave it 5 diamonds. The hotel certainly lived up to that grading! On arrival (on the airport... more

Quiet, despite being on a main road. My brother and I stayed three nights last month, and our rooms were clean, with decently sized bathroom, and comfortable. The staff were helpful and the breakfasts were quite nice. Best of all: the lounge. High ceiling, fireplace, worn but comfy, overstuffed furniture, and an honesty bar. Nothing like returning at the end... more

My husband and I had originally booked another B&B but their renovations had not been completed when we arrived so the owner there had already arranged another reservation for us at the Kildonan at the same rate. I agree with the other reviews. We were given a large room with a spa bath. We had a rather large flat screen... more