Looking at the reviews I think it depends on which apartment you get. We got a two bed appartment and althought the location was great and the flats size was good we found the flat dirty. Large stains on the sofas, a screw sticking up from the floor in the bathroom where the door stop used to be. Think black... More

We stayed 2 nights in the old fishmarket apartment. It was clean and modern, in a good location just off the royal mile. A good choice for a family as reasonably priced, 2 separate bedrooms. Only small issue was a noisy hotwater/heating system which we turned off at night due to the noise. otherwise a good stay. More

just home after a 4 day stay in st giles apartment 3 on easter weekend.3 bed apartment with kitchen and seperate living room.have stayed in edinburgh before but were delighted with this apartment.great location, bang in the middle of the royal mile, just a stones throw away from plenty of restaurants, pubs and clubs. as well as that the apartment... More

The apartment we had (Old Fishmarket Alley) was comfortable, roomy, and the location can't be beat. The bathroom fixtures were a bit old and the sink would probably have come off the wall if you leaned on it (wobbled when I touched it) but by the standards of UK accomodations in this price range, very good. As in any city... More

We have been using trip adviser daily to find accomadation in the UK whilst on a 3 Week road trip . I am hooked,it is the best tool to us when traveling and until today our accomadation has been either what we expected or excelled our expectations. Not so with the St Giles appartments,they lack anylove what so ever and... More

A cautionary note. Having looked at the company web site and previous trip advisor reviews, I think that to avoid any confusion or misunderstanding a clear distinction needs to be made between the St Giles Apartments and the Old Fishmarket Apartments. Although run by the same company they are two completely separate buildings. Our experiences relate to the Old Fishmarket.... More

I have just come back from a three day trip to Edinburgh and it was superb. The city itself is beautiful. I have stayed at St. Ciles Apartments, the ones on the Old Fishemarket Close, and it was excellent. To begin with, its location is perfect becuase they are right on the Royal Mile but on a little Close so... More

Myself & 3 friends have just got back from a brilliant weekend break in Edinburgh & have to say St. Giles apartments are absolutley fab!! This is th 3rd time we have stayed here & can honestly say we haven't came across one fault yet!! This time we stayed in the advocates close apartment which is a 2 bedroom split... More

Stayed in appt 6, top floor. The facilities are top standard. 1 x v large bedroom and 2 medium. Kitchen & bathrooms very modern. Staff on arrival very efficient and friendly. Just 1 drawback - the windows are single glazed sash windows and getting on a bit. This area of town in noisy at night and we didnt get a... More