I had stayed previously across the street in another villa (Cielomar) that the Mahogany Tree folks managed at one time (but did not own). That was lovely, private, in wonderful shape, included the use of a lovely pool and had it's own hot tub. Let's just say that Mahogany is not like Cielomar. Our experience was much like JJShaw, the... more

We spent 9 days at Mahogany tree in Carib Sea and I have to say I was disappointed in the Villa up on our arrival. The web site shows older pics. Im not one that requires 4 or 5 star hotels but I do feel like we were mislead and over charged.. The Home page actually shows the exterior of... more

We stayed here for a week at the end of June. We had looked into hotels, but they are really expensive, and the locations aren't great (we wanted to be within walking distance of Cruz Bay, since parking downtown is so difficult). The villa was really cute inside, the kitchen had everything that you could possibly need, and they provide... more

When we first started thinking about Christmas in St. John's we realized there is not a lot of hotels to choose from. And most private villas don't have websites... but thru deep searches online we came across the Mahogany Tree Villas in Cruz Bay. Cruz Bay is St John's hub for restaurants and shopping- but it is so toned down... more