Would highly recommend the tropical garden suite as it is by far the largest of the four units. With separate living/dining area and galley kitchen, as well as private balcony wrapping around back and side of unit, (inland view) it is the best option for a stay exceeding 1 or 2 nights. The other three units opposite this suite, have... more

We checked in on 12/30 for a four night stay in the Front Suite at Hillcrest. We had been on St. John a few other times, so we found our way in the dark even though Phyllis offered to meet us at the ferry dock. We rented a vehicle from Dependable on St. Thomas and took it over on the... more

We stayed at the Hillcrest for 2 nights. The view is great and it was very nice having the snacks, eggs, etc already in the room when we arrived. As its been stated in other posts Phyllis picked us up at the dock and then gave us a little tour of the city. What really impressed us was Phyllis, the... more

Completed our stay November 12, 2007 and loved it! Our hostess was exceptionally gratious - we were picked up and dropped off at the Cruz Bay ferry - a relevant extra benefit since street addresses are used only loosely in St. John's. Hillcrest is a 5 minute walk from Cruz Bay - be aware that the magnificent view our room... more

We were in St. John for a few days for a wedding at Caneel Bay. Hillcrest Guest House was a perfect place to stay for this wedding. Hillcrest is located near the ferry stop in Cruz Harbor, making it a very convenient location. From the guesthouse you've got to walk about 5 minutes down the hill to catch a taxi... more

We stayed in the Front Suite for 2 weeks. There’s not much to add to the other reviews. It seems how much you like Hillcrest depends on your expectations and desires. Though everyone agrees that Phyllis is the perfect hostess. She is extremely nice, accommodating, genuinely friendly, and helpful. After reading all the reviews here, we expected there would probably... more

We loved St John and cannot wait to go back. Phyllis was wonderful picking us up at the dock and giving great suggestions on places to eat and things to do. We hiked and snorkled almost every day. What a great place to spend a birthday. more

The Hillcrest Guest House is in a nice location. At the top of a hill overlooking Cruz Bay, it offers great views. It is a short, if not easy, walk to anything in Cruz Bay - being at the top of a hill makes it a challenging walk – especially the return. If you are not fit, plan on renting... more

Husband, teen daughter and I stayed in the Southern Suite last week. Owner, Phyllis Hall, is a really sweet lady who accommodated my husbands diabetic diet, offered great advice and a nice, clean room for our stay. The value in staying at Hillcrest is great! Two issues influenced me not being able to rate it higher--location, while having a beautiful... more