My wife and I just spent 5 nights there. It was wonderfully relaxing. We never wandered more than 200 yards from our room in that time. The property is well kept, well run and pleasantly quiet. The beach is lovely and quite private, but be aware that it is short enough that if you love to hike for long stretches... more

I have always thought about writing a review about my stay in Carlisle Bay but never seemed to get round to it but after reading some of the recent reviews i was actually wondering if there was more than one Carlilse Bay and thought i'd better share my views. My wife and I have stayed at Carlisle Bay in May... more

The hotel had very nice staff and very respectable food..above the average. But when I read reviews I always like to know the scoop...is a loud driveway from other hotel close to my room; do we hear the bar noise, is there a dumpster under our window (four seasons wailea) The room was a bit austere and the TV was... more

We did not stay at Carlisle Bay but we went for the day and used there beach and restaurant. The website is beautiful but and says it is 5 Star. I would rate it as 3 star. As soon as you arrive at the front gate and drive along the drive, the road has potholes all over it and the... more

We stayed at Carlisle Bay over Christmas and New Years again this year. We are a family of 8--the grandparents, parents, aunt/uncle and the teenage/college kids. We've traveled extensively and over the holidays have stayed at Caneel Bay, Villa Del Sol in Mexico, La Bonita and Maroma on the Riviera Maya, etc. We LOVE CARLISLE THE MOST! Our Favorite Things:... more

Having read some of the previous reviews we were slightly concerned about what awaited us at Carlisle Bay. We need not have worried! The location of the hotel is beautiful, peaceful and very private. Whilst I would agree that the sea is not the clear turquoise that can be found in other places on the island the bay is nevertheless... more

My husband and I stayed at Carlisle Bay for a week last November. We want to return but I though I'd look at Trip Advisor for Hermitage Bay - just to try somewhere different. I have just read the review below from Sid and it is all about the cost. Carlisle Bay is a beautiful place - so how he... more

My Husband and I stayed at Carlisle Bay for our honeymoon (November 16-23). I was shocked to see how the reviews compared to our stay. We have taken many vacations together as well as with other couples over the past 5 1/2 years together and we always try someplace new. This was a terrible decision this time. The actual entrance... more

Writing this review on a rainy afternoon in my room at Carlisle Bay. This is the last day of my wife's "babymoon". This is our first trip to Antigua as our planned trip to the FS/Nevis was sidetracked by Hurricane Omar and the closure of the FS until the first of the year. Overall, have to say we would have... more