Its hard to rate a comedy club because a lot depends on which comedians are performing on a night you go. The reason I really WANT to give this club a good review is because of 1) the person who sold us tickets & 2) because of the hilarious comedians we saw. I'll start from the beginning and say I... More

We actually decided to try out the comedy club Rodney Dangerfield since we kept getting hounded to buy tickets. We really really enjoyed ourselves. There was about 6 comedians and all of them hilarious. Some were writers from SNL or had been on Comedy Central etc... Definitely check it out. More

Made a last minute decision to go to the "New York Comedy Club" on a Friday evening. I wish I wouldn't have. We called and got reservations at 8PM for the 10PM show, and we were advised to show up at 9:30 to make sure we got in. When we arrived we had to wait outside as the other show... More

Came here last Friday night to see the Clayton Fletcher show - thought he was only mediocre. Much of his advertised jokes which are shown on youtube.com - are his jokes. The rest are pretty lame. The other comedians weren't fantastic - one was outright foul mouthed - would not come to see him again.. try other places in NY... More

First of all, there is a two drink minimum, but they don't actually tell you that until you've already paid to get in. Second, ALL of the comedians were awful! I don't mean that they were raunchy (which some of them were), because I don't mind that. What I do mean is that none of them were funny at all!... More

I bought a travelzoo voucher that was good for this club or their broadway location. I called and made a reservation and then confirmed that this location was the correct location of my reservation. When I arrived, they insisted that: 1. I didn't have a reservation (I called twice to confirm) and 2. The travelzoo voucher was not good there... More

I've love comedy clubs in NYC and NYCC is right in my neighborhood. I live in the Gramercy, and stumbled upon a cool site for comedy clubs. I purchased discount tickets from http://www.bestcomedytickets.com the show was hilarious! We especially liked Wil Sylvince. More

This club doesn't even deserve one star! My friend (she's 5'1" and 105 lbs.) just got back from NY with her 16 year old daughter. They were approached by a man selling tickets to the comedy show. 2 tickets for $20. She asked if the show would be appropriate for a 16 year old and he assured her it would... More

This place was small the comedians were ok. There was a 2 drink minimum which we were not told about. So, we had to pay $25 for 4 bottles of water on top of our tickets. This place is a rip off..STAY AWAY More