If your planning on going to Caption Georges for dinner, you might as pay the extra money for dinner and a show. While the food was good, it was not worth the price nor did it live up to the hype. As for the dinner theater itself, it was quite entertaining but had a few faults. One of the actors... more

We went to Captain George's as part of their "Haunted Dinner" program. The show was ok, but the buffet did not live up to the hype, or the online menu. According to their online description, those who are part of the Mystery Dinner Theater are supposed to have their own buffet, identical to that at which people apparently have to... more

We had a blast. The food was great. You got to go to the buffet once you were seated for about 1/2 hour to 45 min, then after the first scene you got to go back. There were sodas on the table and a cash bar if you wanted a cocktail. The show was not scary at all for my... more

First of all I want to thank the people that run this thing. There was a HUGE mix up with our initial reservation that caused us to have to change several things around on our vacation, but these guys more than said they were sorry. You made our night very special & I thank you for that. Very professionally run... more

A great night out. My wife and I went with our teens and nine year old, and they all had a good time. The buffet was huge - and plenty for the pickiest to find something the like. The acting was cute - not too professional, but better than most murder mystery dinners we've been too. The dinner and act... more

My family & I went to see the Haunted Dinner Theater in Williamsburg. Wow, what a great experience! Instead of standing in the lines to enter Capt. George's Rest. we were able to go right in to the Haunted Dinner Theater room. We ate from the same buffet that's in the restaurant. We had shrimp, crab legs, prime rib, pasta.... more

As I go through photos of vacations past and ponder this summer's family vacation, I remember the fun our whole family had at the Haunted Dinner theater. Our children are 5,9 and 15 and finding something to do that everyone including me and husband enjoy can be challenging, but what so was so great about the Haunted Dinner Theater is... more

We visited the Haunted Dinner Theater on Tues. the 23rd of August and our whole family had a really good time! Prior to our week long trip to Williamsburg I did tons of research (since we had never been) and could not really find a lot of info on this show or the "mystery" one. After comparing what info I... more