Anchor Inn & Cottages
Inn. Price*: US$ 124
81 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #7 in Sanibel Island, FL

Beach Road Villas
Villa. Price*: US$ 185
82 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #5 in Sanibel Island, FL

Beachview Cottages
Resort. Price*: US$ 207
160 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #6 in Sanibel Island, FL

Blind Pass Condominiums
Condominium. Price*: US$ 234
83 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #9 in Sanibel Island, FL

Blue Dolphin Cottages
Motel. Price*: US$ 159
125 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #2 in Sanibel Island, FL

Caribe Beach Resort
Resort
33 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #22 in Sanibel Island, FL

Casa Ybel Resort
Resort. Price*: US$ 351
302 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #8 in Sanibel Island, FL

Castaways Beach and Bay Cottages
Resort. Price*: US$ 220
152 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #19 in Sanibel Island, FL

Colony Resort
Condominium. Price*: US$ 155
30 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #10 in Sanibel Island, FL

Driftwood Inn
Inn
24 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #9 in Sanibel Island, FL

Dunes Golf and Tennis Club
Hotel
3 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #27 in Sanibel Island, FL

Forty / Fifteen
Ranch/Farmhouse/Cottage
7 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #24 in Sanibel Island, FL

Gulf Breeze Cottages
Ranch/Farmhouse/Cottage. Price*: US$ 176
71 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #12 in Sanibel Island, FL

Holiday Inn Sanibel Island
Hotel. Price*: US$ 180
492 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #20 in Sanibel Island, FL

Hurricane House Resort
Condominium
8 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #16 in Sanibel Island, FL

Island Beach Club
Condominium
15 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #23 in Sanibel Island, FL

Island Inn
Resort. Price*: US$ 193
502 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #5 in Sanibel Island, FL

Kings Crown Condominiums
Hotel. Price*: US$ 82
1 review. Traveler rating:
Ranked #29 in Sanibel Island, FL

Kona Kai Motel
Motel. Price*: US$ 100
226 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #18 in Sanibel Island, FL

Lighthouse Resort & Club
Resort
27 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #21 in Sanibel Island, FL

Loggerhead Cay
Condominium. Price*: US$ 203
54 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #15 in Sanibel Island, FL

Mariner Pointe
Hotel
1 review. Traveler rating:
Ranked #28 in Sanibel Island, FL

Mitchell's Sandcastles
Hotel
188 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #1 in Sanibel Island, FL

Ocean's Reach Condominiums
Condominium. Price*: US$ 236
225 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #1 in Sanibel Island, FL

Parrot Nest
Bed and Breakfast. Price*: US$ 159
46 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #4 in Sanibel Island, FL

Pelicans Roost
Condominium. Price*: US$ 301
36 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #3 in Sanibel Island, FL

Periwinkle Cottages of Sanibel
Ranch/Farmhouse/Cottage. Price*: US$ 125
36 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #6 in Sanibel Island, FL

Periwinkle Park & Campground
Cabin/Campground
Traveler rating: not rated

Pine Cove of Sanibel
Hotel
6 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #26 in Sanibel Island, FL

Pointe Santo de Sanibel
Condominium. Price*: US$ 100
212 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #8 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sandalfoot Condominium
Condominium. Price*: US$ 1,397
132 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #2 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanddollar
Condominium
17 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #20 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sandpiper Beach
Condominium
11 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #19 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sandpiper Inn
Inn
25 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #8 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sand Pointe Condominiums
Hotel
22 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #16 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanibel Arms Condominiums
Condominium. Price*: US$ 216
48 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #11 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanibel Arms West Condominium
Condominium. Price*: US$ 238
111 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #4 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanibel Beach Club
Condominium. Price*: US$ 28
11 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #18 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanibel Cottages Resort
Resort
19 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #23 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanibel Inn
Resort. Price*: US$ 213
595 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #9 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanibel Moorings
Resort. Price*: US$ 209
158 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #3 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanibel Siesta Condominiums
Resort. Price*: US$ 190
48 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #7 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanibel Surfside
Condominium
5 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #14 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sayana Condominiums
Condominium
9 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #17 in Sanibel Island, FL

Seahorse Cottages
Motel. Price*: US$ 140
72 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #14 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sea Shells of Sanibel
Condominium. Price*: US$ 121
35 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #22 in Sanibel Island, FL

Seaside Inn
Hotel. Price*: US$ 187
355 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #13 in Sanibel Island, FL

Shalimar Cottages and Motel
Motel. Price*: US$ 193
126 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #10 in Sanibel Island, FL

Shell Island Beach Club
Condominium
14 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #7 in Sanibel Island, FL

Shorewood Condominiums
Condominium
8 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #26 in Sanibel Island, FL

Signal Inn Beach & Raquetball, Inc.
Inn
22 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #6 in Sanibel Island, FL

Song of the Sea
Hotel. Price*: US$ 236
370 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #12 in Sanibel Island, FL

Spanish Cay
Specialty Hotel
Traveler rating: not rated

Sundial Beach Resort & Spa
Hotel. Price*: US$ 217
119 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #25 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sunset Beach Inn
Resort. Price*: US$ 166
377 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #24 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sunshine Island Inn
Inn. Price*: US$ 159
69 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #5 in Sanibel Island, FL

Tarpon Beach Condos
Condominium
15 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #13 in Sanibel Island, FL

Tarpon Tale Inn
Bed and Breakfast. Price*: US$ 114
127 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #1 in Sanibel Island, FL

The Atrium
Condominium
1 review. Traveler rating:
Ranked #27 in Sanibel Island, FL

The PalmView
Inn. Price*: US$ 135
44 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #3 in Sanibel Island, FL

Tortuga Beach Club Resort
Resort. Price*: US$ 350
86 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #4 in Sanibel Island, FL

Tropical Winds Motel & Cottages
Motel. Price*: US$ 203
131 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #15 in Sanibel Island, FL

Villa Sanibel Condominiums
Villa
8 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #25 in Sanibel Island, FL

Waterside Inn on the Beach
Resort. Price*: US$ 186
215 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #11 in Sanibel Island, FL

West-End Paradise
Inn. Price*: US$ 165
99 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #2 in Sanibel Island, FL

West Wind Inn
Resort. Price*: US$ 210
410 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #17 in Sanibel Island, FL

White Caps Cottages
Ranch/Farmhouse/Cottage
7 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #21 in Sanibel Island, FL

Sanibel Harbour Towers
Fort Myers, Southwest Gulf Coast. 3 miles northeast of Sanibel Island
Condominium
1 review. Traveler rating:
Ranked #4 in Fort Myers, FL

Sanibel Harbour Resort Condos
Fort Myers, Southwest Gulf Coast. 3 miles northeast of Sanibel Island
Condominium. Price*: US$ 267
6 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #2 in Fort Myers, FL

Sanibel Harbour Marriott Resort & Spa
Fort Myers, Southwest Gulf Coast. 3 miles northeast of Sanibel Island
Resort. Price*: US$ 195
460 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #24 in Fort Myers, FL

Sanibel Harbour
Fort Myers, Southwest Gulf Coast. 3 miles northeast of Sanibel Island
Condominium. Price*: US$ 303
Traveler rating: not rated

Pink Shell Beach Resort & Marina
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Resort. Price*: US$ 232
1166 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #8 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Abaco Beach Villas
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Hotel. Price*: US$ 299
6 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #35 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Estero Island Beach Villas
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Villa. Price*: US$ 337
9 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #16 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Beach Club I
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Condominium
10 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #13 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Windward Passage Resort
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Condominium
25 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #11 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Cottages of Paradise Point
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Condominium. Price*: US$ 400
12 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #5 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Casa Playa Resort
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Hotel. Price*: US$ 159
292 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #3 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

BEST WESTERN PLUS Beach Resort
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Resort. Price*: US$ 231
489 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #4 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Two Fish Inn
Saint James City, Florida. 5 miles northwest of Sanibel Island
Inn
2 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #2 in Saint James City, FL

Island House Motel
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Condominium
6 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #7 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Bay to Beach
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Condominium
25 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #2 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Edgewater Inn Fort Myers Beach
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Condominium
5 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #18 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Edison Beach House
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Hotel. Price*: US$ 217
270 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #5 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Sandcastle Beach Club
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Resort
10 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #34 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

The Holiday Court
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Motel. Price*: US$ 101
82 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #13 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Manatee Bay Inn
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Bed and Breakfast. Price*: US$ 142
115 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #2 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Shipwreck Motel
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Motel. Price*: US$ 110
86 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #31 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Residence Inn Fort Myers Sanibel
Fort Myers, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles northeast of Sanibel Island
Hotel. Price*: US$ 142
251 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #10 in Fort Myers, FL

Fort Myers Beach Days Inn Island Beach Resort
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Hotel. Price*: US$ 108
5 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #42 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Harbour House at the Inn
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Hotel. Price*: US$ 164
55 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #19 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Lighthouse Resort Inn And Suites
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Resort. Price*: US$ 124
390 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #32 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Pierview Hotel & Suites
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Hotel. Price*: US$ 97
21 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #36 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Sun Deck Inn & Suites
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Motel. Price*: US$ 108
77 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #21 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Matanzas Inn
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Motel. Price*: US$ 79
35 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #29 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Silver Sands Villas
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Villa. Price*: US$ 147
200 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #1 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Beacon Motel
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Motel. Price*: US$ 127
59 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #33 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Hidden Harbor Inn
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Motel
1 review. Traveler rating:
Ranked #37 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

Lani Kai Island Resort Hotel
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Motel. Price*: US$ 126
374 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #41 in Fort Myers Beach, FL

A Beach'n Place
Fort Myers Beach, Southwest Gulf Coast. 5 miles east of Sanibel Island
Guest house
8 Reviews. Traveler rating:
Ranked #4 in Fort Myers Beach, FL